captureplanning.com Tutorials and resources for proposal writing and business development





50 Signs That It Is Time To Re-invent Your Proposal Process

When people working on proposals encounter a problem, they often try to improve their process to resolve the issue. When issues persist, they often blame them on failure to adopt the process. Many organizations struggle for process acceptance and reach a plateau where they can't improve the process because they can't completely implement it. They never realize that the process was flawed from the beginning and is the cause of their problems, not the cure.

Instead of incremental improvements to their process, they really need to start over. Instead of holding on to the process as they initially conceived it, they should re-invent the process to address the organizational realities required for it to succeed.

If many of the items below apply to your organization, it may be time to re-invent your proposal process:

  1. The process calls for storyboards but you never actually do them
  2. Days after the process has started, you still don't have enough people assigned to actually do the proposal
  3. When you need to have a second review because the first one didn't go well, you invent a new color to name it with
  4. The process consists of a kickoff meeting and a red team
  5. The capture manager finds out about the process at the kickoff meeting
  6. Staff cannot execute the process without training
  7. Staff have to be persuaded to follow the process
  8. Executives don't bother to follow the process
  9. People involved in the process do not understand what is expected of them
  10. People involved in the process are not capable of performing what is expected of them
  11. When you're doing a proposal by yourself, you don't bother to follow the process
  12. You don't use the process for "small" proposals
  13. The outline changes after writing has started
  14. You regularly have unanticipated change cycles
  15. You can't get people to stop making changes to the proposal
  16. The process starts at RFP release, or worse, it starts some days after RFP release when someone gets around to telling you about it
  17. You are the only one aware of the process
  18. The process doesn't measure progress
  19. The process doesn't define what a quality proposal is
  20. The process doesn't measure quality
  21. You have trouble preparing the documents required by the process
  22. The process adds to the time it takes to complete the proposal
  23. Reviews are not effective
  24. You don't find out about problems until deadlines are missed
  25. The process requires investing "up front" for an intangible return "later"
  26. The process is not documented
  27. The process is defined as you go along
  28. The execution of the process is different from the written procedures
  29. You frequently find that exceptions to the process are justified
  30. The process is more about production than it is about winning
  31. By the time you're ready to start work, staff have already started writing the first draft
  32. People in field offices have never heard of the process
  33. People do not see the process as helping them complete their assignments
  34. The only guidance writers get is what is in the RFP
  35. You have a review (probably called a Red Team)
  36. If you have more than one review, there is no integration between them
  37. Reviewers get no written guidance
  38. Reviews do not have an assigned leader
  39. Reviewers are not required to add value to the proposal
  40. You decide how comments should be collected when you get to the review
  41. The reviewers are the same as the writers
  42. The process requires everyone to be physically present/co-located
  43. You have post-proposal lessons learned meetings, but never formally change the process as a result
  44. You finish the proposal and you're not really sure what's in it
  45. You're adding themes and win strategies at the end of the effort
  46. Conflicts revolve around edits instead of message
  47. Proposals are regularly delivered at the last possible minute
  48. You routinely have a mad crunch at the end with rapid last minute changes displacing your final quality assurance checks
  49. You find yourself saying "if people would only follow the process, all these problems would go away" multiple times a day
  50. The pricing proposal is almost never done early enough to check and make sure that it actually agreed with what you promised in the technical approach

If these apply to you, then you need to ask yourself if your current process is serving everybody's needs. Chances are that it is not and that you would be more successful by designing a process around an assessment of everyone's needs instead of the conventional wisdom regarding how proposals "are supposed" to be done.

Fulfilling your needs for planning, coordination, expectation management, resource allocation, quality validation, etc. are far more important than how you go about it. If your current process is not fulfilling those needs, stop beating your head against a wall and start over with a fresh approach.

Click here for more free articles like this one



By Carl Dickson,
Founder of CapturePlanning.com and PropLIBRARY



PropLIBRARY is our professional tool for people who want to win RFPs like their business depends on it.


Get our apps for Android devices:

Gig Pipeline: For business development and proposal consultants

Get Help Winning: Helps companies find consultants and resources for winning


Browse hundreds of free articles on all these topics:

Advice for Better Proposal Writing
How to Write a Business Proposal
Proposal Management
Red Teams & Proposal Quality Validation
How to Create a Compliance Matrix
Process and Procedures
Win Strategies and Themes
How to Write an Executive Summary
Professional Services Marketing
Proposal Templates and Reuse
Miscellaneous Proposal Tips
Storyboards and Content Planning
Government Contracting
Request for Proposals (RFP)
Bid/No-Bid Decisions
Business Development and Marketing
Relationship Marketing and Customer Contacts
Sales Letters & Copy Writing




About Us | Privacy Policy | Contact Us

Copyright © 2015. Please view the Terms of Use prior to copying or distributing. This site is part of the CapturePlanning.com Network.